We have been grilling pizzas for a while. In fact, for many years this recipe has been our signature dish. We’re so excited to finally post so others can use it.
I believe it was around 2003 when I first saw Bobby Flay toss raw dough on a grill from across the room and completely blow my mind.
At the time I was watching the Food Network pretty religiously. I remember thinking, “If this guy can fling raw pizza dough 20 feet across the room and land it on the grill, then I’m pretty sure I can carefully slide it on a grill and find success.”
So in classic David style, I didn’t do a trial run with just my wife and myself first. No, I got my boss and several coworkers and their families together for our very first grilled pizza party. What a way to peel back that onion, right?
And you know what? It totally worked.
Brisket Grilled Pizza Recipe:
This particular pizza recipe was created during one of our amazing grilled pizza parties when we had a huge selection of toppings available to cover our pizzas with. Our counters practically looked like a grocery store.
It just so happens that I had smoked a delicious brisket a couple of days prior and we had some leftover that we decided at the last minute to add to the buffet.
You can cook your brisket however you want, whether it be charred, grilled or smoked. We just smoked it and then chopped it up and added it to our assortment of condiments.
Part of the fun of grilled pizza parties is that you can be adventurous with your toppings and explore new things that you might not taste otherwise.
The best part about a grilled pizza party is getting to cook delicious concoctions that only you like. For example, if you’re into crispy pizzas with sun-dried tomatoes, a whole cup of olives, basil, rosemary and onion, but want to go light on the parmesan cheese, then go for it! You can cook whatever your heart (or taste buds) desires!
You can use bigger pieces of dough to cook a bigger pizza to share with the whole family, given that your grill has enough space for a full pizza. Once you taste this recipe, though, you might not want to share any pieces, regardless of how big your pizza is.
This chopped brisket grilled pizza is a tried and true winning combination that is a sure-fire win in my book. Here’s what it includes:
- Bbq sauce
- chopped smoked brisket
- red onions, thinly sliced and lightly sautéed
- fresh mozzarella
- feta cheese
- crispy fried onions
- After we cooked the pizza, we garnished with fresh basil or cilantro
How to Prepare Homemade Pizza Dough for the Grill
Making homemade pizza dough really isn’t that complicated. The hardest part is learning how to warm up the water to the correct heat for the sake of the yeast. I have a laser infrared thermometer that helps take the guess work out of that.
When using active dry yeast the water should be between 105-110 degrees for optimal proofing.
We always mix our pizza dough in our KitchenAid stand mixer.
Take it step by step when making pizza dough.
- Proof the yeast. Combine the warm water (105-110 degrees), yeast, and sugar in the mixing bowl and just let it be for 10 minutes. You will see that over time it starts to expand and bubble on the top, much like the froth of freshly poured root beer.
- Add the dry ingredients and oil. Gently add the flour, salt, oil, and any additional teaspoons or tablespoons of seasoning, depending on how much seasoning you want. (we like to add garlic powder, Italian seasoning, and a tiny bit of red pepper flakes). Use the dough hook to mix those ingredients together for a couple of minutes. It should eventually form a ball on the hook that basically cleans the mixer of any remaining ingredients remaining behind.
- Time to rise. When I grill pizza, I like to divide the dough into individual servings right away. I spray a Pyrex dish or cake pan with cooking spray, load dough balls inside, and cover with plastic wrap for a couple of hours. Some people use a cooking sheet, but I’ve found this method to be more successful. Over time they will expand and nearly double in size and shape.
Grilled Pizza Recipe
- large spatula
- KitchenAid stand mixer
- 2 tsp active dry yeast
- 1 tsp sugar
- 3/4 cup warm water between 105-115 degrees
- 2 1/4 cup flour
- 1 tsp salt
- 2 Tb olive oil
- ¼ tsp garlic powder
- ¼ tsp Italian seasoning
- ¼ tsp red pepper flakes
- In a stand mixer, combine warm water, yeast and sugar in a bowl and allow to sit and proof for about 10 minutes. It should expand and develop a frothy bubbled top.
- Carefully add flour, salt, seasonings and oil to the bowl and use a dough hook to knead the dough for about 3 minutes until the dough forms a nice ball and has cleaned the sides and bottom of the bowl.
- Divide the dough into 4 equal balls. Place into a dish that has been sprayed with nonstick cooking spray and cover with plastic wrap. Set aside for 2 hours to rise.
- Heat your grill up nice and hot between 450-500 degrees preferably.
- On a lightly floured surface, roll each of your dough balls out using a rolling pin or just your hands.
- Once the grill is hot, carefully lay the rolled dough on the grill grate and close the lid for about 90 seconds.
- Turn the grill temperature down to a medium low now and carefully transfer the pizza back to the grill. Close the lid and let it cook for another 5-10 minutes depending on the thickness of the toppings.
How to Throw a Grilled Pizza Party
Literally hundreds of people have grilled pizzas on my grill over the past 15 years.
My wife and I were small group leaders at our church for about a dozen years and those who were in our group always looked forward to at least a spring and a fall grilled pizza party.
We’ve done staff get-togethers as grilled pizza parties. We’ve done them for large groups of volunteers I was managing in my previous work. Family reunions. Birthday parties. We even donated a grilled pizza party once for a private school auction fundraiser. Either for lunch or dinner, this meal will be a hit.
So all that to say that we’ve learned a few things over the years on how to be successful throwing a grilled pizza party. Here are some relatively simple things to consider:
How Many People Do You Invite to a Grilled Pizza Party?
Well, how big is your grill? We have a 5 burner Jenn Air gas grill that can let about 8-9 pizzas enter it at a time. It’s a beast of a gas grill. So we have served a group as big as about 45 before, just knowing that we won’t all be sitting down to eat at the same time.
You can use any type of grill that you want for your pizzas. Many people use charcoal grills, others use gas. We choose the grill that we do because of the sheer number of pizzas that we can prepare at once with it.
One of the benefits to having a big group is that you end up with a bigger buffet of extra pizza toppings to choose from!
What Should the Guests Bring to a Grilled Pizza Party?
When we throw a grilled pizza party, we provide the dough, drinks, paper plates, paper cups, and the rest of the paper products, and the guests bring everything else.
We provide a huge sheet, almost like an advertisement, of potential choices and everyone signs up in advance for whatever items they’d like to bring. Usually 3-4 things per family.
The bigger the group, the more elaborate the buffet of additions can be for your meal.
Guests are advised to come with their toppings already prepared for the buffet. So any food or topping that needs cut up or pre-cooked should be ready before arriving. For instance, someone bringing a pound of chicken might want to cook it before arriving. Otherwise, you’ll obviously have to wait for the pound to get fully cooked before using it, and that’s no fun.
Depending on the size of the group, we might limit the options for people to choose from so that you have enough of the more traditional toppings available.
Some, like pepperoni, sausage, and onion go very quickly. Others, like rosemary, basil, and olives go at a much slower pace (for obvious reasons).
The cheese is what you’ll always need the most of, so make sure that whoever is bringing that plans for more than just a few cups, or ask multiple people to bring a bag. Almost everyone will sprinkle some (or a lot) of it on their pizzas, so prepare properly.
Grilled Pizza Toppings
- Pizza Sauce
- Alfredo Sauce
- Pesto Sauce
- BBQ Sauce
- Pulled Pork
- Shredded Mozzarella cheese
- Fresh Mozzarella cheese
- Feta Cheese
- Goat Cheese
- Cheddar Cheese
- Green Pepper
- Sweet Bell Peppers
- Banana Peppers
- Onions (Thinly sliced)
- Fresh Spinach
- Fresh Basil
- Fresh Cilantro
- Italian Seasoning
- Fried Onion
We also usually have some guests bring salads, chips, or desserts in addition to the pizza toppings. It’s nice to have other things to munch on while waiting for your turn to cook your pizza.
How to Make Things Run Smoothly
Station 1: Dough Rolling
All the dough should be pre-divided into individual balls for each guest. You can have the guests roll their own dough, although we’ve found that this always takes longer. If efficiency is what you’re looking for, designate one or two people that can roll the dough for all. We dust the paper plates with flour before we slide the rolled dough on it so that the dough doesn’t stick to the paper plates.
Station 2: Grilling the first side of the pizza
Once you have enough homemade dough to fill your grill, go ahead and load it up to cook off the first side. Flip those crusts back onto their plates and send them into the next station.
Station 3: Toppings Buffet
You’ll want to arrange your buffet in a logical progression. The stack of cooked pizza crust should go first, followed by all the sauce options, meat options, vegetable and green options, shredded cheese options, garnishes, etc.
Station 4: Return to the grill
By now, hopefully the first phase of cooking crusts is complete and the set heat of the grill can be turned down a bit. You’ll want to be careful to not open the hot grill more than necessary, so try to wait until you have a full grill again before beginning. The set amount of time it takes each pizza to finish cooking will entirely depend on how many extra additions they’ve added to their pizza. You could save some time and put lightly topped pizzas on first, but where’s the fun in that? As one pizza comes off, transfer a new one in its place.
Station 5: Pizza Cutting
After the dough rolling station has been cleaned up, we usually replace that area with a good-sized cutting board and our handy pizza cutter.
Cooking grilled pizza has become a tradition in our family and friend groups. It’s literally the first thing I want to do when the cold winter temperatures break and the first signs of spring arrive. I hope you give it a try. It’s great as a lunch or dinner… or even breakfast.
You’re all set to start cooking grilled pizzas for your own parties! I think you’ll find that your friends and family will be more than content with the results.
Drop a comment below if you can think of toppings for our pieces of pizza that we left out and need to add to the list. Or tell us what your favorite topping combination is! Maybe we’ll have to try your recipe next.
We hope that this post was helpful to you and that you’ll be back to The Barbecue Lab for more recipes, gear reviews, grill reviews, and other great content.